Thanks. Yes to fiber, all ports set to 1000-full, and this is the type of AT&T circuit that's functionally point to point with no AT&T switching in the middle (the reality is that there's at least a Ciena 6500 between the two routers) so they have no ports to configure.
I understand what you're saying about layer 1 but we had four of these circuits completed recently and none of them worked at first but with some AT&T testing and some reconfiguration and some luck of the gods, two of them came up and I'm not really sure how that happened so I keep thinking there's some tweaking I can do to bring these last two up. Plus we ordered our equipment to spec so there are no switches, sfps or fiber cables to swap out. And AT&T says all their stuff is fine.